Klaw and Erlanger

Klaw and Erlanger was an American theatrical management and production partnership founded in New York City in 1888 by Marc Klaw and Abraham Lincoln Erlanger. The firm combined theatrical booking, touring management, Broadway production, theater ownership, and related commercial activities. Its influence was strongest in the southern United States, where the partners developed control over important touring routes and theater relationships while maintaining a substantial operating base in New York. The partnership began when Klaw and Erlanger acquired the H. S. Taylor Theatrical Exchange. Klaw brought legal training, theater contacts, and experience as a critic, while Erlanger had developed practical expertise as a theater treasurer and business manager for touring companies. Their booking operation expanded beyond agency work into a network of allied enterprises, including an opera company, a costume business, and construction activities. They also produced plays and musicals, managed performers and touring attractions, and acquired interests in theaters in New York and New Orleans. Klaw and Erlanger became especially important through their role in the Theatrical Syndicate, established in 1896 with Charles Frohman, J. Fred Zimmerman Sr., Samuel F. Nixon, and Al Hayman. The syndicate coordinated bookings across a large network of first-class legitimate theaters and introduced a more standardized national system for scheduling productions, assigning venues, and negotiating engagements. At its height, the system was associated with bookings for more than 500 theaters. The arrangement reduced some of the inefficiencies of fragmented touring, but its concentration of market power generated opposition from independent producers, performers, and the Shubert brothers. The firm’s most visible architectural project was the New Amsterdam Theatre, which opened in New York on October 23, 1903. The lavish building included a large Broadway playhouse, offices for the partnership, and the rooftop Aerial Gardens. The latter became closely associated with the Ziegfeld Follies, which used the venue for a series of productions beginning in the 1910s. Klaw and Erlanger also held an ownership interest in Chicago’s Iroquois Theatre. A devastating fire at that theater on December 30, 1903, killed more than 600 people and triggered severe public criticism, litigation, and reputational damage for the partners. The Theatrical Syndicate’s effective monopoly weakened after sustained competition from the Shuberts and criticism of its restrictive booking practices. By 1910, the syndicate had lost much of its market dominance, although Klaw and Erlanger continued to participate in its affairs. The partners also experimented with vaudeville, most notably through the United States Amusement Company, created with Lee and J. J. Shubert in 1907 and sold later that year to E. F. Albee. Between approximately 1913 and 1916, they entered film production, although theater remained their central business. Klaw and Erlanger dissolved their partnership in 1919. Marc Klaw subsequently operated independently, including through the Klaw Theatre, while Erlanger remained active in theatrical management and the syndicate’s business. Erlanger died in 1930 and Klaw in 1936. The partnership is remembered for helping create a national commercial theater infrastructure, for the prominence of its Broadway venues and productions, and for the controversies surrounding concentrated control of theatrical bookings and the Iroquois Theatre disaster.

Marc Klaw and Abraham Lincoln Erlanger formed their partnership in New York in 1888 after meeting in San Antonio and purchasing the H. S. Taylor Theatrical Exchange. Klaw had studied law, practiced as an attorney, and maintained connections with theater through criticism and management contacts. Erlanger had worked as treasurer of Cleveland’s Euclid Avenue Opera House and later as a business manager for touring companies associated with performers including Joseph Jefferson. Their complementary backgrounds allowed the new firm to combine legal and commercial organization with practical touring knowledge. The partners expanded the acquired booking agency into a broader theatrical enterprise. Klaw’s relationships with theater owners helped the company establish influence over touring routes in the South, anchored by New Orleans, while the firm also developed a major Broadway presence. Its activities included booking attractions into theaters, producing plays and musical shows, managing tours, owning or operating venues, and running related companies such as the Klaw and Erlanger Opera Company and a costume enterprise. The partnership also participated in theater construction and development. In 1896, Klaw and Erlanger joined Charles Frohman, J. Fred Zimmerman Sr., Samuel F. Nixon, and Al Hayman in establishing the Theatrical Syndicate. The syndicate sought to coordinate the booking of legitimate theatrical productions into a national network of first-class theaters. By standardizing arrangements and concentrating relationships among theater owners and producers, it created a more efficient alternative to the fragmented touring system of the period. Klaw and Erlanger’s southern theater connections formed one of the network’s most important geographic bases. The system eventually encompassed bookings associated with more than 500 theaters. The syndicate’s success also made it a target. Independent producers and performers objected to its leverage over venues and engagements, while the Shubert brothers developed an organized rival network under the banner of independent theater. The syndicate’s control was further challenged when its members attempted to enter or influence adjacent forms of entertainment, including vaudeville. Although its effective monopoly was broken by about 1910, it continued to operate with substantial holdings and influence for years afterward. Klaw and Erlanger invested in and managed several theaters. Their most ambitious project was the New Amsterdam Theatre, opened in October 1903 in New York. Designed by Herts & Tallant, the building combined a large Broadway auditorium with elaborate decorative work and offices for the partnership. The rooftop Aerial Gardens was added soon afterward and became a prominent venue for the Ziegfeld Follies. The partnership produced the first Follies in 1907, and the New Amsterdam later hosted the series for much of the 1910s. Other associated New York houses included the Gaiety Theatre, Liberty Theatre, and New York Theatre; in New Orleans, the partners owned or operated the Tulane and Crescent theaters. The same year the New Amsterdam opened, the Iroquois Theatre in Chicago began operations. Klaw and Erlanger held a 25 percent interest and managed its bookings. On December 30, 1903, the theater burned during a holiday matinee, killing more than 600 people. The event became one of the deadliest fires in American history and provoked sustained criticism of the theater’s construction, safety arrangements, and management. The partners retained attorney Levy Mayer amid criminal and civil proceedings. They also sued Life magazine over a cartoon attacking them in connection with the disaster, but the jury rejected the libel claim almost immediately. Press criticism, including material directed personally at the partners, continued for years. The firm’s principal business remained legitimate theater, but it made several adjacent-market experiments. In 1907, Klaw and Erlanger joined Lee and J. J. Shubert to create the United States Amusement Company, an ambitious vaudeville booking operation marketed as advanced vaudeville. The venture was sold to E. F. Albee later that year, with the partners agreeing not to re-enter vaudeville for a specified period. From roughly 1913 to 1916, the partnership also participated in film production, extending its production experience into an emerging medium. Klaw and Erlanger dissolved their partnership in 1919. Klaw later pursued independent theater activities, including the Klaw Theatre on Broadway, while Erlanger remained a powerful figure in the continuing Theatrical Syndicate and broader theatrical management. Erlanger died in 1930 and Klaw in 1936. Historically, the partnership is significant both for its role in building a national theater-booking infrastructure and for illustrating the commercial, competitive, and safety controversies created by concentrated control of American theatrical venues.

• 1919

  Partnership dissolved

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  Klaw and Erlanger ended their formal partnership and continued theatrical activities separately.

• 1910

  Syndicate monopoly weakened

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  Shubert competition and opposition to the syndicate’s booking power ended its effective monopoly over first-class legitimate theater.

• 1907

  First Ziegfeld Follies

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  Klaw and Erlanger produced the first Ziegfeld Follies at New York’s Jardin de Paris.

• 1903

  New Amsterdam Theatre opens

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  The partnership opened its flagship Broadway theater, a major playhouse with offices and a rooftop performance space.

• 1903

  Iroquois Theatre fire

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  A catastrophic fire at the Chicago theater, partly owned by the partners, killed more than 600 people and generated extensive criticism and litigation.

• 1896

  Theatrical Syndicate founded

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  Klaw and Erlanger became founding members of a national booking alliance with several other leading theatrical managers.

• 1888

  Partnership established

  [1]Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org

  Marc Klaw and Abraham Lincoln Erlanger formed a theatrical partnership in New York after acquiring the H. S. Taylor Theatrical Exchange.

A vertically integrated theatrical enterprise combining production, booking, venue ownership, and touring management. Its commercial strength came from linking Broadway production with a national network of first-class theaters, particularly across the southern United States.

• Theatrical production · 1888

  Legitimate theater productions

  The partnership produced Broadway and touring plays, musicals, and large-scale theatrical attractions. Its production activity was integrated with its booking network, allowing shows to be developed, promoted, and routed through theaters connected to the broader syndicate system.

• Theater management · 1888

  Theatrical booking network

  Booking was the firm’s core commercial capability. Klaw and Erlanger coordinated engagements between touring productions and first-class theaters, particularly in the South, and helped operate the national booking structure of the Theatrical Syndicate.

• Theater venue · 1903

  New Amsterdam Theatre

  Opened in 1903, the New Amsterdam was the partnership’s flagship Broadway venue. Its large auditorium, elaborate architecture, company offices, and rooftop Aerial Gardens made it both an operating theater and a visible symbol of Klaw and Erlanger’s commercial stature.

• Musical revue · 1907

  Ziegfeld Follies

  Klaw and Erlanger produced the first Ziegfeld Follies in 1907. The revue later became strongly associated with the Aerial Gardens and New Amsterdam Theatre, helping establish the partnership’s role in fashionable large-scale Broadway entertainment.

• Vaudeville booking · 1907

  United States Amusement Company

  Created with Lee and J. J. Shubert in 1907, this venture represented Klaw and Erlanger’s largest attempt to enter vaudeville booking. It was sold to E. F. Albee later the same year.

• Film production · 1913

  Film production

  The partners experimented with motion-picture production from approximately 1913 to 1916, extending their theatrical production business into an emerging entertainment medium.

• 1903

  Iroquois Theatre disaster

  The Iroquois Theatre in Chicago, partly owned by Klaw and Erlanger and booked by them, burned during a holiday matinee on December 30, 1903. More than 600 people died. The partners faced intense public criticism and civil and criminal litigation concerning the theater’s safety and management. Their libel action against Life magazine over an attack related to the disaster was dismissed.

  Source

Read more

• 1919

  Dissolve the partnershipOther

  Background

  The partners had spent decades operating a diversified theatrical business, while continuing market changes affected the syndicate and Broadway.

  Action taken

  Klaw and Erlanger ended their formal partnership and pursued separate activities.

  Aftermath

  Klaw continued independently, including through the Klaw Theatre, while Erlanger remained active in theatrical management and the Theatrical Syndicate.

  Source

• 1907

  Enter vaudeville bookingStrategy

  Background

  Klaw and Erlanger and the Shuberts sought to participate in the growing vaudeville business and make use of available theater capacity.

  Action taken

  They jointly established the United States Amusement Company, described as an advanced-vaudeville booking operation.

  Aftermath

  The venture was sold to E. F. Albee in November 1907, and the partners agreed to stay out of vaudeville for a period.

  Reported capitalization. (1907)

  • E. F. Albee — Albee acquired the operation and paid an additional reported bonus in exchange for the partners’ withdrawal from vaudeville.

  Source

• 1903

  Open the New Amsterdam TheatreProduct launch

  Background

  Klaw and Erlanger sought a prestigious New York base that could combine theatrical operations, production, and venue ownership.

  Action taken

  The partners opened the New Amsterdam Theatre on Broadway, with a large auditorium, offices, and later the Aerial Gardens rooftop theater.

  Aftermath

  The venue became a major platform for Broadway productions and the Ziegfeld Follies.

  Source

• 1896

  Create a coordinated national booking systemStrategy

  Background

  American theatrical touring was fragmented, with producers and venues negotiating through inefficient and inconsistent arrangements.

  Action taken

  Klaw and Erlanger joined other major managers to form the Theatrical Syndicate and coordinate bookings across first-class legitimate theaters.

  Aftermath

  The system became highly influential and was associated with bookings for more than 500 theaters, but its concentration of power provoked opposition from performers, independent producers, and the Shuberts.

  • Shubert brothers — The Shuberts promoted independent theater and built a rival network that helped break the syndicate’s effective monopoly.

  Source

1. 1Klaw and Erlangeren.wikipedia.org