United Church of Canada controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile5 entries
2015
Gretta Vosper ministry dispute
Minister Gretta Vosper's public identification as an atheist and earlier writing questioning the continuing usefulness of God-language led to a formal suitability review. A 2018 settlement allowed her to continue serving at West Hill United.
1997
Debate over Bill Phipps's theological comments
Soon after becoming moderator, Bill Phipps drew public criticism after questioning the traditional Christian understanding of Jesus's divinity in a newspaper interview.
1988
Internal conflict over LGBTQ inclusion
The decision to permit openly gay people in ordained ministry produced organized opposition, congregational splits, and ministerial resignations.
1980
Residential-school abuse and institutional responsibility
The United Church operated or supported residential schools within Canada's assimilation system for Indigenous children. Former students later brought allegations and lawsuits involving abuse and institutional harm, prompting apologies, financial responses, and continuing reconciliation work.
1972
Controversy over United Church Observer article on Zionism
An article by editor A. C. Forrest criticizing Israel and arguing that Zionists influenced news coverage triggered criticism from members and B'nai Brith Canada and damaged relations with parts of the Canadian Jewish community.