Lidl controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile10 entries
2022
European chicken welfare controversy
Animal-welfare organizations released investigations into farms supplying Lidl in Germany, Italy, and Spain. The footage was described by campaigners as showing injured, sick, and poorly treated broiler chickens, including birds unable to walk and animals living in heavily contaminated conditions. NGOs urged Lidl to adopt the European Chicken Commitment and improve supplier-welfare standards.
2021
Sicarev recalls mislabeled beef steaks sold by Lidl
Recall announced
Farmers' cooperative Sicarev recalled L'étal du boucher 2 Pavés Charolais Label Rouge steaks sold by Lidl because the packaging showed an expiry date of May 24, 2021, instead of April 24, 2021. Customers were advised to eat them before April 24 or return them to Lidl; reimbursement was available even without a receipt.
Farmers’ cooperative Sicarev recalled the L'étal du boucher 2 Pavés Charolais Label Rouge steaks sold by Lidl because the packaging showed an expiry date of May 24, 2021, instead of April 24, 2021. Customers were advised to eat them before April 24 or return them to Lidl; reimbursement was available even without a receipt.
Company response
Refund or compensation — Lidl
Customers can be reimbursed for the mislabelled steaks even if they do not have a receipt.
Source excerpt
Instead of April, 24, 2021, the date on the packaging reads May 24, 2021.
Customers can be reimbursed for the mislabelled steaks even if they do not have a receipt.
Farmers’ cooperative Sicarev is recalling the product “2 Pavés*** Charolais Label Rouge 260g” from the brand L'étal du boucher, sold by Lidl.
2021
NGO files complaint against German companies over alleged Xinjiang forced labor
Lawsuit filed
The European Center for Constitutional and Human Rights filed a complaint against five German companies, including Hugo Boss and Lidl, accusing their executives of covering up and profiting from possible forced labor in Xinjiang. The organization asked Germany's Federal Prosecutor General to investigate possible forced labor and the companies' potential legal responsibility; the article does not report a finding that the allegations were proven.
Company response
Ongoing disclosure — Lidl
Lidl公司将会“持续、系统地核查潜在的风险,如供应链中是否存在侵犯人权的现象”,并“在必要时采取措施予以纠正”。
Clarification — Hugo Boss
针对供应商的一些指控,Hugo Boss也对生产企业进行了自我审查,并没有发现强迫劳动的迹象。
Source excerpt
非政府组织欧洲宪法和人权中心对成衣企业Hugo Boss和连锁超市Lidl等5家德国企业提出诉讼,指控这些企业的负责人包庇新疆可能存在的强迫劳动并从中获益。
针对供应商的一些指控,Hugo Boss也对生产企业进行了自我审查,并没有发现强迫劳动的迹象。
Lidl公司将会“持续、系统地核查潜在的风险,如供应链中是否存在侵犯人权的现象”,并“在必要时采取措施予以纠正”。
2021
Dole recalls packaged salads over possible Listeria contamination
Recall announced
Dole Fresh Vegetables announced a voluntary recall of Dole-branded and private-label packaged salads processed at its Bessemer City, North Carolina, and Yuma, Arizona, facilities due to possible Listeria monocytogenes contamination. The source says the decision followed findings of the bacteria in samples from two products and notes that the implicated strain is believed by FDA and CDC to be responsible for at least sixteen illnesses since 2014.
Company response
Recall — Dole Fresh Vegetables, Inc.
Dole Fresh Vegetables, Inc. has announced that they are voluntarily recalling all Dole-branded and private label packaged salads processed at its Bessemer City, NC and its Yuma, AZ production facilities from the market due to possible contamination with Listeria monocytogenes.
Remediation — Dole Fresh Vegetables, Inc.
According to the Food and Drug Administration, Dole is also temporarily suspending operations at both facilities to conduct their extensive cleaning and sanitation protocol.
Source excerpt
The decision to suspend operations and recall all products from those facilities was made after finding, and analyzing, the strain of Listeria monocytogenes that was isolated in a single package of Dole-branded Garden Salad produced in the Bessemer City facility and a single package of shredded iceberg lettuce produced in the Yuma, AZ facility.
The recalled products come from the following brands: Ahold, Dole, Kroger, Lidl, Little Salad Bar, Marketside, Naturally Better, Natures Promise, and Simply Nature.
Dole Fresh Vegetables, Inc. has announced that they are voluntarily recalling all Dole-branded and private label packaged salads processed at its Bessemer City, NC and its Yuma, AZ production facilities from the market due to possible contamination with Listeria monocytogenes.
2020
Court temporarily bars Lidl access-road construction in Riga
Ruling
Latvia's Administrative District Court barred Lidl from constructing an access road to its Dzelzavas Street store in Riga because the project was presumed unlawful. The article reports that the temporary measure could be appealed and remained in place until a final verdict.
Source excerpt
the ban is a temporary measure until the final verdict is delivered.
Administrative District Court has banned German retailer Lidl from constructing an access road to its store on Dzelzavas Street in Riga as the project is presumed to be unlawful
2020
Lidl recalls two pesto products over possible undeclared peanuts
Recall announced
In May 2020, Lidl recalled two types of pesto because they may have contained undeclared peanuts. The recall was reported as a product-safety action concerning the possible presence of an undeclared allergen. The source states that Lidl is recalling two types of pesto because they may contain undeclared peanuts. No further details on specific products, affected batches, or outcomes were provided in the available information.
Source excerpt
Lidl is recalling two types of pesto over fears that the products may contain undeclared peanuts.
2020
Lidl pledges review of Maryport store safety measures
Company response
In August 2020, Lidl pledged to review safety measures at its Maryport superstore after safety lapses at the store were criticised. The commitment followed criticism of those lapses, and the retailer stated that it would examine the safety measures in place at the Maryport location. The event was reported under the headline that Lidl pledged a review of safety measures at the Maryport store, with the accompanying summary noting that the promise came after criticism of safety lapses. No further details on the specific lapses, the scope of the review, or its outcome were provided in the available material.
Lidl promised to review safety measures at its Maryport superstore following criticism of safety lapses.
Company response
Investigation — Lidl
Lidl has promised to review safety measures at its Maryport superstore.
Source excerpt
Lidl has promised to review safety measures at its Maryport superstore.
2020
Lidl recalls roast chicken pieces over Listeria
Recall announced
A recall was issued for a batch of Glensallagh Family Pack Roast Chicken Breast Pieces due to the presence of Listeria. The product was sold in Lidl stores nationwide, and consumers were told not to eat it while stores were asked to stop selling it.
Company response
Recall — Lidl
Lidl have issued an urgent recall of its chicken products because salmonella contamination has been found in some of it’s the products in a batch.
Source excerpt
The Glensallagh Family Pack of Roast Chicken Breast Pieces are sold in Lidl stores nationwide.
Anyone who bought one of the implicated products is being told not to eat it, while stores have been requested to stop selling them.
A recall of a batch of roast chicken pieces has been issued due to the presence of Listeria.
2017
Trade-union and works-council allegations
Trade unions in Germany accused Lidl of closing or reorganizing stores when employees sought to establish works councils or participate in collective bargaining. The allegations concerned labor relations and the company’s treatment of employee representation.
2008
Allegations of employee surveillance
Journalists reported that Lidl had monitored employees in Germany, including allegations involving private telephone calls, personal relationships, and off-duty movements. Lidl said the monitoring was intended to deter theft and identify abnormal behavior. The episode generated criticism over workplace privacy and corporate surveillance practices.