Reception
The series holds an average rating of 7.6 by 41 professional critics on the review aggregation website Comic Book Roundup.[18][19][20][21]
Jesse Schedeen, in IGN 's review of issue #1, compared it to the original Secret Warriors by Jonathan Hickman and said, "fans of the original Secret Warriors comic will need to keep their expectations firmly in check for Vol. 2". He highlighted that the only linkage between the volumes is Daisy Johnson – "it's certainly less espionage-focused and more of a traditional superhero comic". Schedeen commented that "it doesn't help that Daisy does little to stand out as the main protagonist. Rosenberg focuses mainly on her disillusionment with S.H.I.E.L.D. in the wake of Captain America's betrayal, but even that does little to lend sympathy to her cause. [...] Javier Garron at least brings an energetic feel to the series".[22]
In his review of issue #4 for IGN, Schedeen commented that "Marvel did this series no favors at all by giving it the 'Secret Warriors' branding and inviting unwarranted comparisons to the previous volume. The good news is that the series is starting to find its footing, even if it continues to share little in common with its namesake. The increased emphasis on Daisy's moral relativity and the conflict between her and her more idealistic teammates gives the book some much-needed dramatic weight. [...] Javier Garron's figure work is still a problem at times, both in the weirdly exaggerated, distended facial expressions and the wonky perspective".[23]
Tara Bennett, in IGN 's review of issue #5, wrote that "Secret Warriors has been a weird series for me personally because I loathe Secret Empire with my every being, and couldn't care less about the Inhumans, but this Secret Empire tie-in, starring the Inhumans, is so freaking good. It's a great successor to the Secret Warriors title, featuring heroes who are engaged in nothing less than treason, kidnapping, espionage, thievery, and murder. [...] For a long time, Marvel's been trying to make us care about Inhumans. For the first time since the Ellis/Zaffino Karnak series, they've succeeded".[24]
Joshua Davison, in Bleeding Cool 's review of issue #12, commented that "honestly, I am pretty disappointed to see this book get canned. [...] It's one of the last gasps of the Inhumans in Marvel. Just because Marvel made a huge mistake in trying to position them as the new X-Men, that doesn't mean the Inhumans are a terrible group of characters".[16] On issue #12, Davison called it "pretty good" and "endearing".[16] He highlighted that Ramon Bachs' "art isn't particularly impressive, but it's not awful either. [...] Matthew Rosenberg sends the Secret Warriors off in a cute and fun tale of mending bridges and respecting differences".[16]
On the series cancellation, Kofi Outlaw for ComicBook.com said, "this 2017 iteration of the Secret Warriors was born out of the 'Secret Empire' crossover, which wasn't Marvel's most acclaimed event (to say the least). It seems as though Marvel has been trying to wrap up all things 'Secret Empire' and tie the storylines off, setting the stage for new chapter. Despite solid critical and fan acclaim, Secret Warriors may just be another casualty of that situation. Writer Matthew Rosenberg and artist Javier Garron managed to gather one of the oddest collection of Marvel heroes we've ever seen, and yet, made this quirky weird family work, while providing some exciting ties to the larger Marvel Universe - often in unexpected ways".[7]