Critical reception
While criticising the pace of the play due to how closely it mirrored the movie, Sarah Hemming of the Financial Times gave it five stars, praising the portrayal of the main characters and called the play a "gorgeous, uplifting tribute to the link between theatre and the imaginative realm of children's play".[20] The Daily Telegraph Dominic Cavendish also observed that the pace was due to the film, but called it "intoxicating [and] detail-savouring". Awarding it four stars, he compared it to a pantomime but ultimately praised it as a "vital power surge of Anglo-Japanese creative electricity fit for these soul-sapped times".[21]
In a five-star review in The Guardian, Arifa Akbar compared the play to the movie, writing that there was a "different imagination at work here, but it is just as enchanting and perhaps more emotionally impactful". She highlighted the puppeteers' role, calling them a "human field of corn, swaying as one" and describing Totoro as "formidable, rumbling, eerie, comic and endearing at once".[22] Also praising their role was its sister paper's Susannah Clapp, praising them in a four-star review as the "souls of the creatures and the real pulse of the play".[23] Identically giving it four stars, Johnny Oleksinski of the New York Post called for the play to be shown on Broadway, saying that it "balances jaw-dropping effects with soul and emotional intelligence" and it played host to "one of the most stunning theatrical images in years".[3]
Cautioning that watching Totoro would lead to "sore cheeks" from the "two and a half hours you'll spend grinning from ear to ear", The Independent Annabel Nugent gave it four stars; she likened the set's ability to adapt to origami but said that the music was occasionally not a strong enough partner to the "splendour of the visual storytelling".[24] Writing in The Times, Clive Davis also picked out the music for criticism in a four-star review, attacking it as "so insipid" but praising the protagonists' portrayal, puppeteers, and set.[25]
Giving it four stars in its Sunday edition, Quentin Letts called the play "likeably impassive [and] lightly surreal". He said that its lack of evil was a double-edged sword, but admitted that the play would probably be a good fit for children.[26] Likewise focusing on the light nature was Nick Curtis of the Evening Standard, who stated in a three-star review that Totoro needed "more jeopardy, more darkness and more of the monsters". Comparing Totoro to another play, Matilda, that he believed the Royal Shakespeare Company were trying to emulate, he said it was not "quirky or adult-friendly enough" to be the same, saying that it was "easier to admire than to love".[27] Also making a comparison between the two plays was Matt Wolf of The New York Times, who said that they were "family entertainment that adults might like even more than children". While criticising the quick changes in tone for the ending as the play's one error, Wolf called the "kindness, empathy and generosity of spirit" "infectious".[28]
On 8 December 2022, it was announced that My Neighbour Totoro led the nominations for the 2023 WhatsOnStage Awards, earning nine nominations.[29] My Neighbour Totoro came fifth on The Independent's best theatre of 2022 ranking.[30]