In September 2005, RealLiveGuys.com marketing director Eddie K characterized Corbin Fisher as one of the "new hit gay porn sites that specialize in straight guys."[28] In July 2008, Falcon Entertainment CEO Todd Montgomery said he admired the company and its development, "I've always had a lot of professional and personal admiration for [Corbin Fisher] because they really defined a new space in gay adult entertainment that didn't exist prior to the real broad adoption of the Internet."[29] In August 2008, Gary Blumenthal, manager of a different pornographic site, OnTheHunt.com, commented on the focus of Corbin Fisher and Sean Cody, "Both http://www.SeanCody.com and http://www.CorbinFisher.com are niche-specific Web sites focusing on all-American jock-type guys, many of whom are 'gay for pay.'"[30]
In December 2007, Dylan Fox of Gaywired.com noted that Corbin Fisher had become successful; "gay man's obsession with straight guys has created a booming Internet business that is raking in the cash."[31] The Spanish language media site ENewspaper also commented on this phenomenon, observing that Corbin Fisher had successfully capitalized on appealing to those that appreciate videos where supposedly heterosexual men act in gay film.[32]
Ernie Alderete of Bay Area Reporter reviewed the color photo collection Corbin Fisher's Amateur College Men distributed by Bruno Gmunder, and described it as "a collection of exciting color photos of college-age athletes in sexual poses progressing from soft-core to fully erect and stiff hard-core".[33] Alderete criticized the focus of pictures in the book and the book's size, "But several factors prevent Amateur College Men from achieving greatness. Inexplicably, several of the photographs are out of focus."[33] His review concluded, "Despite its flaws, this book is packed with interesting faces and nice bodies, the stuff many dreams could be made of. And it certainly lives up to its name: it delivers tons of absolutely fresh, USDA prime meat!"[33]
In April 2009, ENewspaper classified Corbin Fisher in the world of gay pornography as among "website suppliers of videos", including Sean Cody, RandyBlue.com, CockyBoys, and StraightBoysFucking.com.[34]
In June 2009, Jason Salzenstein of Edge Boston commented favorably of the Corbin Fisher-produced photo book Playing Hard to Get distributed by Bruno Gmunder, "In fact, one of the best things about this volume is its simplicity, and the natural beauty of the models. When 'boy next door' has come to mean Abercrombie & Fitch perfection, it's refreshing to see a book filled with guys who actually look like they could live in your neighborhood."[35] Carsten Weidemann of the German language site Queer.de gave Playing Hard to Get a positive review, and noted that Corbin Fisher became successful quickly, calling the site "athletic, sexy".[36]