Reception
Bakuman was chosen as the best manga for male readers in the 2010 Kono Manga ga Sugoi! guidebook, which surveys people in the manga and publishing industry.[45] It was nominated for the third annual Manga Taishō award in 2010.[46] The first volume of the series placed fourth on the Oricon manga chart during its debut week, selling 154,675 copies.[47] The second volume followed suit, placing second during its first week with 228,056 copies.[48] The third volume continued the trend and placed fourth during its debut week, selling 200,369 copies.[49] During the first half of 2009, the first volume placed twenty-eighth and the second volume placed twenty-seventh on Oricon's list of fifty top-selling manga in Japan, selling 381,633 and 394,567 copies respectively.[50] Bakuman was the seventh best-selling manga series of 2011, with almost 4.4 million copies sold, and the tenth best of 2012, with over 3.2 million sold that year.[51][52] By April 2012, over 13 million copies had been sold,[53] with this number growing to over 15 million copies in publication by May 2014.[37] In the United States, volume one debuted at number 6 on The New York Times Manga Graphic Books list for the week of August 12[54] and remained on the list for eight weeks straight.[55]
Jason Thompson referred to Bakuman. as "a love letter to the manga industry done in old-school shonen manga style." He felt that while it can be "text-heavy" on the process of making manga, it is ultimately a "heroic story of self-improvement, friendship and striving to succeed." Thompson cited the villain characters as the most interesting, but called the series sexist for only portraying its female characters as either "bitter, man-hating viragos motivated by grudges against men" or "patient helpmates" striving to support them instead.[56] Carlo Santos of Anime News Network was surprised that Bakuman succeeds, not only as a manga about manga, but as a slice-of-life story about the dreams of youth. Although he praised the conflicting viewpoints of the protagonists, Santos remarked that the series could learn from Ohba and Obata's previous serial Death Note; commenting that the beginning is not as gripping and the plot twists are "pretty weak" and "seem like petty contrivances." Despite this, he believes that the series is "another hit."[57] Allegra Frank of Polygon seems to disagree with Santos' criticism, calling Bakuman. a "sweet, funny page-turner" that is gripping right from the start just like Death Note, only in "a completely different, far more low-key way".[58]
Christopher Butcher reviewing volume one for About.com had strong praise for the art, calling it "quite possibly the best-drawn manga out today." He also enjoyed the behind-the-scenes information on the manga industry. Like Thompson, Butcher did state that while he enjoyed it, he has reservations about recommending Bakuman. because it is "horribly sexist."[59] In an article discussing the underdevelopment of its female lead characters, Gregory Segal of Comic Book Resources wrote that some fans speculate the series' inclusion of such tropes is a form of meta-commentary on the traditional portrayal of women in manga.[60]
The film was number-one at the Japanese box office on its opening weekend, with US$2.1 million.[61] It earned US$1.15 million during the October 18 weekend.[62] At the 39th Japan Academy Prize awards, its editor Yasuyuki Ōzeki won the Japan Academy Prize for Best Film Editing award, while Sakanaction's Motion Music of Bakuman won the Outstanding Achievement in Music award.[63] The film was also one of two releases that won the Popularity award, alongside Maku ga Agaru.[63] Matt Schley of Otaku USA wrote that Bakuman. is "a real celebration of and testament to the unique power of Japan's comics culture" and the best live-action manga adaptation he's seen this year.[64] Kotaku's Toshi Nakamura also suggested that it is possibly the best live-action manga adaptation he's seen. However, he said the motivational romance between Mashiro and Azuki was "surprisingly inconsequential" and boring.[65]